We have Mapfre (aka Commerce) on our 2 vehicles and 2018 19.
I am not aware of any MA insurance company that offers replacement value after the first year.
Our 2014 19 was destroyed by our neighbor's tree and Mapfre covered it under the auto policy comprehensive, see our post
here. The reimbursement was the depreciated value, but it did reflect Escape's minimal depreciation. The process was not painless, but I must say that Mapfre did pretty well and I remain a loyal customer.
FWIW, our annual cost is $233 for collision (line 7) and comprehensive (line 9) with a $1000 deductible and a $54 credit for a 99 merit rating.
Bill R